Should Manchester United Move for Ollie Watkins? The Case for a Proven Premier League Striker

Ollie Watkins has emerged as a potential target for Manchester United this summer, with journalists such as Ben Jacobs reporting ongoing interest. As the club explores ways to strengthen its attacking options, Watkins continues to be mentioned and for good reason. With a proven record in the Premier League and a reliable goal return, he could offer a dependable boost to United’s front line.

We have all watched Ollie Watkins in the Premier League for years and one thing is crystal clear, he is one of the most consistent strikers in Europe. Watkins isn’t just a goal poacher. He’s a complete forward with the ability to link play, bring others into the game, and still deliver consistently in front of goal. For a side like Manchester United that’s struggled to find balance in attack, Watkins could be exactly the kind of no-nonsense, Premier League-tested striker they need.

From a tactical standpoint, the players who stands to gain most from Watkins’ arrival is potentially new signings Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo. Watkins thrives alongside creative midfielders and No.10s, using intelligent movement and sharp combinations to open up space. He’s as comfortable finishing chances as he is creating them, a rare trait in today’s centre forwards.

Over the past five league campaigns, Watkins has delivered:

• 75 goals in 184 Premier League appearances
• Double figures in each of the last five seasons
• 13+ goal contributions (goals + assists) in every campaign since 2020
• A club record at Aston Villa: first player to hit 15+ league goals in three consecutive top-flight seasons

It’s not just output, it’s consistency.

Why Watkins Makes Sense for United

• Premier League Experience – No adjustment period needed. Watkins knows the league, the defenders, the intensity and still delivers. 
• Durability – Across five seasons, he’s missed very few games. You’re not just buying goals; you're buying reliability.
• Link-up Play – He's not a one-dimensional forward. Watkins complements ball carriers and attacking midfielders, making him a perfect foil for United’s developing core.
• No Guesswork – Unlike younger strikers, there’s no ‘maybe’ with Watkins. You know what you’re buying and you know he will deliver.

But There Are Downsides

• The Price Tag – At £60m, Aston Villa are asking for a premium. While Watkins’ record might justify it, United’s current transfer strategy leans more toward long-term resale value, something a 29-year-old striker doesn’t offer.
• Limited Resale Value – At almost 30, there’s little chance of recouping the fee. This goes against INEOS’ recent preference for younger, high-upside talent.
• Not a Glamour Signing – Watkins isn’t flashy. He’s not going to sell shirts or grab headlines. His value is in the hard yards and final product, something fans will appreciate, but the board may hesitate over.

If Manchester United want guaranteed Premier League goals, Watkins is about as safe a bet as you can get. He’s consistent, adaptable, and proven, and his 127 goal involvements in 223 games across all competitions prove it.

But it comes down to valuation. At £60m, it’s hard to justify not because he’s not worth it, but because the club’s long-term planning prioritises upside and resale. At £45m or lower? It starts to look very appealing.

It might not be the 'big name' signing United fans demand, but it could be a smart one.